Home / Blog / The Diner Drink, Reborn: Egg Creams and Cherry-Lime Rickeys for the Home Bar

Need it fast?

Order by 2:00 PM EST for next business day shipping.

Plus, enjoy FREE next-day delivery in Manhattan, Williamsburg, Long Island City, and Astoria!

Call 855.313.3028

The Diner Drink, Reborn: Egg Creams and Cherry-Lime Rickeys for the Home Bar

The Diner Drink, Reborn: Egg Creams and Cherry-Lime Rickeys for the Home Bar

Both come back with a bottle of syrup, a bottle of seltzer, and a tall glass. Add cold milk for the egg cream and a lime for the rickey, and that is the full shopping list for two drinks you now have to make yourself. A long spoon and two minutes cover the rest.

What You'll Learn

  • Why an egg cream has no egg or cream, and who usually gets the credit
  • How to build one with a thick foam, and why New Yorkers fight over the syrup order
  • How a bourbon saloon drink from the 1880s became a cherry-lime soda fountain rickey
  • What a Manhattan Special float adds to the same home counter

What is an Egg Cream?

The egg cream contains no egg and no cream, which is the first thing everyone says about it and the last thing anyone can explain. A Lower East Side candy store owner named Louis Auster usually gets the credit for inventing the drink. The name has at least three origin stories, and nobody has settled any of them. The recipe is the part with no argument: chocolate syrup, cold milk and seltzer, built in a tall glass until the top turns into a white foam.

Purists insist on Fox's U-Bet, a Brooklyn syrup that dates to the early 1900s. Its founder, Herman Fox, is said to have named it after a Texas oil venture that fizzled, and he came home with nothing but the phrase "you bet." Any thick, old-fashioned chocolate syrup in the same style makes a respectable one.

How Do You Build an Egg Cream?

Chill a tall glass if the freezer has room. Pour in about a quarter cup plus two tablespoons of cold whole milk. Whole milk matters, since anything leaner waters the drink down. Tilt the glass and pour in very cold seltzer from a good height until the foam nears the rim. Spoon in two tablespoons of chocolate syrup last and stir gently with a long spoon until it blends under the foam. Drink it right away, because the foam fades fast.

New Yorkers argue about the order of operations. Many put the syrup in last to protect the foam. Others pour it in first. Pick a side and defend it at the counter.

Canned seltzer works fine if it is ice cold and you pour from a height. Canada Dry Seltzer Water Original comes in 24-can cases at Beverage Universe.

How Do You Build a Cherry-Lime Rickey?

The rickey started in Washington, D.C., at a saloon called Shoomaker's in the 1880s, where it was bourbon, lime, and sparkling water. Later, soda fountains dropped the bourbon and added fruit syrups, including cherry and raspberry.

Fill a tall glass with ice. Squeeze in half a lime and drop the shell in after it, the way the original was served. Add about two tablespoons of cherry syrup, top with cold seltzer, then stir once. Taste it. Adjust from there: more lime if it runs sweet, a little more syrup if it runs sour. A maraschino cherry on top finishes it. Adults who want to honor the 1880s original can add bourbon.

The Third Leg: A Manhattan Special float

Coffee soda belongs at the same counter. Manhattan Special has been made in Brooklyn since 1895 and comes in glass bottles at Beverage Universe, from 6-packs up to cases of 24. Drop a scoop of vanilla ice cream into a cold glass and pour the soda slowly down the side so the foam stays in the glass. Diet and diet decaf versions are available for anyone counting calories or hours of sleep.

Stock the Home Bar

Keep four things on hand: chocolate syrup, cherry syrup, a case of seltzer, and a bag of limes. Milk lives in the fridge already. The label says to put chocolate syrup in the fridge once it's open. Keep sealed seltzer on a shelf so the bar stays ready for whoever drops by. A bottle of Manhattan Special in the door means a float is one scoop away.

Beverage Universe ships next business day on orders placed by 2:00 PM EST, with free next-day delivery in Manhattan, Williamsburg, Long Island City and Astoria. These are New York drinks, so it seems right that the delivery is New York fast.

Egg Cream and Rickey FAQ

Is there egg in an egg cream?

There is no egg and no cream. The drink is chocolate syrup, cold milk, and seltzer.

Do I need Fox's U-Bet to make one?

Purists say yes. Any thick, old-fashioned chocolate syrup makes a respectable egg cream, though the flavor will differ.

How do I keep the foam from collapsing?

Start with cold whole milk and very cold seltzer, pour the seltzer from a height, and drink the egg cream right away. The foam fades fast.

What is a cherry-lime rickey?

It is the soda fountain version of the rickey: lime, cherry syrup and cold seltzer over ice. The original 1880s rickey used bourbon instead of syrup.